Skip to Content
Calculator

Physical gold vs
gold ETF calculator

A gold ETF gives you a share of a fund that holds gold. Physical gold gives you the gold. Same price chart, two very different things to own. See what each one really costs over the years you plan to hold, and what you actually have in your hands at the end.

Physical gold You own it Metal in your name. Coins and bars you can hold No fund, no trust, no middleman No yearly fee if you store it yourself
Gold ETF You own shares A claim on a fund. Shares in a trust that holds gold A custodian, a trustee and a broker A fee every year, for as long as you hold
GLD yearly fee
0.40% Charged every year, paid out of the gold in the fund
Yearly fee on gold you hold
$0 Kept at home or in your own safe
Our buyback payout
1 to 3 days Business days after we receive and verify your metals
Run the numbers

Paper or physical?
Do the math.

Enter what you would invest and how long you would hold it. Pick an ETF, pick where you would keep your metal, and hit Calculate. No sign-up, no email.

Your numbers
Physical gold
Gold ETF
Gold growth is your assumption, applied to both. Physical: premium on the way in, spread on the way out, storage each year. ETF: expense ratio each year plus brokerage and bid-ask costs, half when you buy and half when you sell.
After 10 years, if you sell
Physical gold $155,773
Gold ETF (GLD) $156,333
The ETF costs less here Over 10 years, the ETF costs about $561 less. Hold 11 years or more and physical pulls ahead. Either way, only one of them puts gold in your hands.
Physical cost $7,117
ETF cost $6,556
Lines cross Year 11
Value if you sold, year by year Year 10: physical $155,773 · ETF $156,333
$88K $107K $126K $145K $164K Buy Yr 2 Yr 4 Yr 6 Yr 8 Yr 10
Physical gold Gold ETF (GLD)
Own the real thing →
Side by side

Same gold price.
Not the same thing.

An ETF follows the price of gold. Physical gold is the gold. Here is what that difference means the day you need it.

Physical gold compared with a gold ETF
Physical gold Gold ETF
What you own Physical gold: Coins and bars, by weight and serial number Gold ETF: Shares of a trust that holds gold
Who stands between you and your gold Physical gold: No one, if you hold it. A fully insured, independent depository, if you vault it. Gold ETF: A trustee, a custodian, a sponsor and your broker
Can you take delivery? Physical gold: Yes. It ships to you, insured. Gold ETF: Generally no. Only large firms can redeem shares, in big blocks.
Yearly cost Physical gold: $0 at home. As low as 0.30% of value in our vault. Gold ETF: 0.10% to 0.40% a year, every year
One-time cost Physical gold: Premium to buy, spread to sell Gold ETF: Brokerage and bid-ask spread
When you can sell Physical gold: Lock a buyback quote with us, paid 1 to 3 business days after we receive and verify your metals Gold ETF: During market hours, in seconds
In an IRA Physical gold: Yes, in a Gold IRA at an approved depository Gold ETF: Yes, in a regular brokerage IRA
What the numbers miss

Price is one number.
Ownership is everything.

01

A fee that never stops

An ETF fee looks tiny. But it comes out every year, from the gold itself, whether gold rises or falls. Hold long enough and you pay it on a much bigger number. Physical gold charges you at the door and at the exit, and nothing in between if you keep it yourself.

02

A promise, or the metal

An ETF share is a promise kept by a chain of institutions: the trust, its custodian, its sponsor, your broker. Every link has to work on the day you sell. Gold in your hands is no one's promise. That is the whole reason people buy it.

03

Built for the bad day

People buy gold for the moment the system wobbles: a crash, a bank run, a currency that keeps losing value. That is the one moment you want the fewest people between you and your wealth. On that day, metal you own beats a ticker you trade.

Questions

Physical gold vs ETFs,
answered.

Is a gold ETF cheaper than physical gold?
Sometimes, and it depends on how long you hold. Physical gold costs you once: a premium when you buy and a spread when you sell. A gold ETF costs you every year: an expense ratio taken out of the fund, whether gold goes up or down. Over a short hold the ETF often costs less. The longer you hold, the more that yearly fee adds up. The calculator shows the year the lines cross.
Can I turn my gold ETF shares into real gold?
Usually not. Large gold ETFs such as GLD and IAU create and redeem shares only with authorized participants, the big financial firms that trade in blocks of many thousands of shares. Individual shareholders sell their shares for dollars. If you want gold you can hold, you need to buy the metal itself.
How does an ETF's expense ratio actually get paid?
The fund sells a little of its gold to pay its costs. That means each share holds slightly less gold every year. With GLD at 0.40%, a share holds roughly 4% less gold after ten years than it does today. It is easy to miss, because you never see a bill.
What does physical gold cost to own?
Three things: the premium over spot when you buy, the spread under spot when you sell, and storage if you do not keep it yourself. At Everlasting Wealth our premium is capped at 9.9% over our wholesale cost, and is often just a few dollars over spot. Our buyback pays 0% to 3% under live spot. Vault storage starts as low as 0.30% of the value stored.
Can I hold physical gold in an IRA?
Yes. A Gold IRA holds IRS-approved coins and bars at an approved depository in your name. You get the metal, not shares of a fund, inside a retirement account. Talk to a specialist or see our Gold IRA guide to learn how it works.

Don't own a promise. Own the gold.

Live prices, a premium capped at 9.9% over our wholesale cost, and a 100% buyback guarantee. For cash or for your IRA.

Sources: fund expense ratios as published by their sponsors and reported by etf.com and 24/7 Wall St, 2026. Results are estimates for education only and assume the same gold price for both. They leave out taxes, which can differ, and ETF tracking differences. This is not investment or tax advice. Precious metals carry risk and may rise or fall in value.